Peer Reviewer Process

JEDBUS
Peer Review Process
JEDBUS (Journal of Economic and Digital Business) applies a double-blind peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process.
Double-Blind
Review model
Min. 2
Reviewers per manuscript
Editor
Makes the final decision
STEP BY STEP
Review Workflow
1
Submission
The author submits the manuscript through OJS following the Author Guidelines.
2
Initial Screening
The editor checks scope, completeness, formatting, anonymisation, and language. Manuscripts outside the scope or not following the template may be returned or rejected at this stage.
3
Similarity Check
The manuscript is checked for plagiarism in line with the Screening for Plagiarism policy.
4
Reviewer Assignment
The editor assigns at least two reviewers with expertise in economics, digital business, or a related field. Reviewers have no conflict of interest with the authors.
5
Peer Review
Reviewers evaluate the manuscript and submit their comments and recommendation through OJS.
6
Editorial Decision
The editor considers the reviewers’ reports and decides to accept, request revisions, or reject the manuscript.
7
Revision
Authors revise the manuscript and upload the revised version with a response to reviewers. Revised manuscripts may be sent back to reviewers.
8
Acceptance and Publication
Accepted manuscripts are copyedited, laid out, proofread by the authors, assigned a DOI, and published in the next available issue.
WHAT REVIEWERS ASSESS
Review Criteria
Relevance Fit with the focus and scope of JEDBUS in economics and digital business.
Originality & Novelty Clear research gap and new contribution to theory or practice.
Methodology Appropriate research design, sampling, data collection, and analysis.
Results & Discussion Accurate findings, discussion supported by literature, and practical implications.
Clarity Logical structure, clear writing, and correct use of tables and figures.
References Relevant, up to date, and formatted in APA 7th edition.
POSSIBLE OUTCOMES
Editorial Decisions
Decision Meaning
Accept Submission The manuscript is accepted without further changes.
Revisions Required Minor revisions; the editor checks the revised manuscript.
Resubmit for Review Major revisions; the revised manuscript is reviewed again.
Decline Submission The manuscript is rejected and will not be considered further.
INTEGRITY
Ethics in Peer Review
  • Manuscripts are treated as confidential documents. Reviewers must not share or use the content for their own work.
  • Reviewers must declare any conflict of interest and decline the invitation if one exists.
  • Reviews should be objective, constructive, and respectful, supported by clear arguments.
  • The use of AI tools to evaluate or write review reports with confidential manuscript content is not allowed.
  • Authors may appeal an editorial decision through the Complaints and Appeals Policy.

Submit a ManuscriptReviewersPublication Ethics