Complaints and Appeals Policy

JEDBUS
Complaints and Appeals Policy
JEDBUS (Journal of Economic and Digital Business) welcomes feedback and handles complaints and appeals in a fair, transparent, and timely manner, following the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Complaint
An expression of dissatisfaction about the journal’s processes, policies, editorial handling, or the conduct of editors, reviewers, or staff.
Appeal
A formal request by an author to reconsider an editorial decision, usually a rejection, based on new evidence or a clear error in the review.
SCOPE
What Can Be Raised?
Editorial Process Unreasonable delays, lack of communication, or failure to follow the stated procedures.
Peer Review Concerns about bias, conflict of interest, or the quality of review reports.
Editorial Decision Disagreement with a rejection or a decision considered to be based on a misunderstanding.
Published Content Errors, copyright issues, or ethical concerns in a published article.
Misconduct Suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, or other misconduct are handled under the Allegations of Research Misconduct policy.
PROCEDURE
How to Submit a Complaint
1
Send Your Complaint
Email lppm@uym.ac.id with the subject “JEDBUS Complaint”, addressed to the Editor in Chief.
2
Provide Details
Include your name, the article title or submission ID, a clear description of the issue, and any supporting evidence.
3
Acknowledgement
The editorial office acknowledges receipt of the complaint.
4
Review
The Editor in Chief reviews the complaint. If the complaint concerns the Editor in Chief, it is handled by another senior member of the editorial board or by LPPM Universitas Yatsi Madani.
5
Response
The complainant receives a written response explaining the outcome and any action taken.
PROCEDURE
How to Appeal an Editorial Decision
1
Submit an Appeal
The corresponding author emails lppm@uym.ac.id with the subject “JEDBUS Appeal” and the submission ID.
2
Explain the Grounds
Provide a detailed, point-by-point explanation of why the decision should be reconsidered, responding to the reviewers’ and editor’s comments with evidence.
3
Reconsideration
The Editor in Chief reviews the appeal and may consult the original handling editor, the reviewers, or an independent expert.
4
Final Decision
The author is informed of the outcome. The decision on an appeal is final.
GOOD TO KNOW
Important Notes
  • Only one appeal per manuscript will be considered.
  • Appeals must be based on a clear reason, such as a factual error or evidence of bias. Disagreement alone is not sufficient.
  • A manuscript under appeal must not be submitted to another journal until the appeal is concluded.
  • If the original decision is reversed, the manuscript may be sent for further peer review.
  • All complaints and appeals are handled confidentially and without prejudice to the complainant.
  • Abusive or threatening communication will not be accepted.

Submit a Complaint or AppealPeer Review ProcessPublication Ethics