Allegation of Research Misconduct

JEDBUS
Allegations of Research Misconduct
JEDBUS (Journal of Economic and Digital Business) takes all allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously. Allegations are handled fairly, confidentially, and in line with the guidelines and flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
TYPES OF MISCONDUCT
What Is Research Misconduct?
Fabrication Making up data, respondents, interviews, or results and reporting them as real.
Falsification Manipulating research materials, survey responses, or data analysis, or omitting data so that the results are not accurately represented.
Plagiarism Using another person’s ideas, text, data, or results without proper acknowledgement, including self-plagiarism. See Screening for Plagiarism.
Duplicate Publication Publishing the same or substantially similar research in more than one journal, or submitting to several journals at the same time.
Authorship Misconduct Ghost, gift, or honorary authorship, or adding or removing authors without consent. See Authorship and Contributorship Policy.
Citation Manipulation Excessive self-citation or citation coercion intended to inflate citation metrics.
Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest Failing to disclose financial or personal interests that could influence the research.
Ethical Violations Collecting data from respondents, businesses, or digital platforms without consent, or disclosing confidential personal or business information.
Peer Review Manipulation Suggesting fake reviewers or misusing confidential manuscripts during review.
REPORTING
How to Report an Allegation
  • Allegations can be submitted by anyone (readers, reviewers, editors, or other researchers) by email to lppm@uym.ac.id, addressed to the Editor in Chief of JEDBUS.
  • Please include the article title or submission ID, a clear description of the concern, and supporting evidence (e.g., links, similarity reports, or documents).
  • Anonymous reports will be considered if they are supported by sufficient and verifiable evidence.
  • The identity of the person reporting is kept confidential.
STEP BY STEP
Investigation Procedure
1
Receipt and Initial Assessment
The Editor in Chief acknowledges the report and assesses whether the allegation is relevant and supported by evidence.
2
Evidence Collection
The editorial team gathers relevant information, such as similarity reports, data, review records, and correspondence, without prejudging the case.
3
Contacting the Authors
The authors are informed of the concern and given a fair opportunity to explain and respond.
4
Evaluation
The Editor in Chief, with the editorial board and, where needed, independent experts, evaluates the evidence and the authors’ response following COPE flowcharts.
5
Institutional Involvement
For serious cases, the journal may inform the authors’ institution and request an institutional investigation.
6
Decision and Action
The editor decides on the outcome and informs all parties concerned.
CONSEQUENCES
Possible Outcomes
No Misconduct Found The case is closed and the manuscript continues through the normal process.
Minor Issue The authors are asked to correct the problem, e.g., by adding missing citations or clarifying text.
Before Publication The manuscript may be returned for revision or rejected.
After Publication A correction, expression of concern, or retraction may be published. See Retraction, Withdrawal & Correction.
Serious or Repeated Misconduct The authors’ institution may be informed, and the authors may be banned from submitting to JEDBUS for a certain period.
FAIR PROCESS
Principles
  • All parties are treated fairly and confidentially, and authors are presumed innocent until the investigation is complete.
  • Decisions are based on evidence and documented in the journal’s records.
  • Authors may appeal the outcome following the Complaints and Appeals Policy.

Report a ConcernPublication EthicsContact Us