Article Types
JUBIR
Article Types
JUBIR (Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour and Research) accepts four types of manuscripts in entrepreneurship and entrepreneurial behaviour. Choose the type that best fits your work before submitting.
|
01
Original Research Article
New empirical findings on entrepreneurship
|
02
Case Study
In-depth analysis of a business, MSME, or startup
|
03
Review & Trend Analysis
Critical synthesis of literature and emerging trends
|
04
Conceptual Paper
Theoretical contribution and new frameworks
|
DECISION GUIDE
Which Type Fits My Manuscript?
| I collected and analysed new data (survey, interview, experiment, secondary data). | Original Research Article |
| I examined one or a few specific businesses, MSMEs, startups, or entrepreneurs in depth. | Case Study |
| I reviewed and synthesised previous studies, or analysed trends in entrepreneurship. | Review & Trend Analysis |
| I propose a new model, framework, or theoretical argument without new empirical data. | Conceptual Paper |
AT A GLANCE
Comparison of Article Types
| Type | Purpose | Typical design | Key content |
| Original Research | Test or explore relationships in entrepreneurship | Quantitative, qualitative, or mixed methods | Hypotheses or research questions, data analysis, findings, implications |
| Case Study | Explain how and why a business phenomenon happens in a real context | Single or multiple case design | Case background, data sources, analysis, lessons learned |
| Review & Trend Analysis | Map what is known and identify gaps or trends | Narrative, systematic, scoping, or bibliometric review | Review method, synthesis, research agenda |
| Conceptual Paper | Build or extend theory | Theory-driven argumentation | Propositions, framework, theoretical and practical implications |
TYPE 01 · REQUIREMENTS
Original Research Article
| Title, Abstract, Keywords | As in the Author Guidelines; abstract in Indonesian and English, 3–5 keywords. |
| Introduction | Background, research problem, literature gap, novelty, and objectives or hypotheses. |
| Literature Review | Relevant theories (e.g., entrepreneurial intention, opportunity recognition, business strategy) and hypothesis development. |
| Methods | Research design, population and sample, instruments, data collection, and analysis techniques. |
| Results and Discussion | Findings supported by numbered tables or figures, compared with previous studies, with practical implications for entrepreneurs and MSMEs. |
| Conclusion | Answers to objectives, limitations, and suggestions for future research. |
| References | Minimum 20 references in APA 7th edition. |
TYPE 02 · REQUIREMENTS
Case Study
| Introduction | Context of the case and why it is important for entrepreneurship research or practice. |
| Case Background | Profile of the business, MSME, startup, or entrepreneur (identity may be anonymised). |
| Methods | Case selection, data sources (interviews, documents, observation), and analysis approach. |
| Case Analysis | Problems, decisions, strategies, and outcomes, linked to relevant theory. |
| Lessons Learned | Practical insights and recommendations for entrepreneurs, managers, or policymakers. |
| Ethics | Permission from the business owner and protection of confidential business data. |
TYPE 03 · REQUIREMENTS
Review & Trend Analysis
| Introduction | Background and the review question or objective. |
| Review Method | Databases, search keywords, time span, inclusion and exclusion criteria, and selection process. Use PRISMA for systematic reviews. |
| Synthesis | Thematic grouping of studies, key trends, and comparison of findings. Not merely a summary. |
| Discussion | Strength of evidence, research gaps, and a future research agenda. |
| Conclusion | Main contributions of the review and implications for research and practice. |
TYPE 04 · REQUIREMENTS
Conceptual Paper
| Introduction | The theoretical problem or puzzle and why a new perspective is needed. |
| Theoretical Foundation | Critical discussion of existing theories and their limitations. |
| Proposed Framework | The new model, framework, or propositions, preferably with a figure. |
| Discussion | Theoretical contributions, practical implications, and how the framework can be tested. |
| Conclusion | Summary of the argument and directions for empirical research. |
FOR ALL TYPES
General Notes
| Author Guidelines | All types must follow the Author Guidelines for formatting, citation style (APA 7th), ethics, and submission. |
| Template | Use the official JUBIR template for every article type. |
| Review Process | All manuscripts undergo editorial screening and double-blind peer review. |
| Assignment of Type | If the type is unclear, the editors may assign the most suitable type during initial assessment. |
| Acceptance | Meeting the requirements does not guarantee acceptance. Non-compliant manuscripts may be returned before review. |



